Transformations of Gender and Race: Family and Developmental Perspectives

Tukey follow-up tests revealed that, consistent with our hypothesis, parents in both traditional and divergent families had significantly lower income than those in egalitarian families. Consistent with our expectation, a Tukey follow-up test revealed that parents in both the traditional and divergent families had significantly lower levels of education than parents in egalitarian families.

This SES index was used as a control variable in all remaining analyses. Hypothesis 2 b posited that parents in families characterized by more traditional gender role attitudes would have a more traditional division of household labor. Tukey follow-up tests for the main effects for cluster showed that mothers in the divergent group spent more time on feminine household tasks than did mothers in the egalitarian group, and that fathers in the egalitarian group spent more time on feminine household tasks than fathers in both the traditional and divergent groups.

The overall parent effect indicated that mothers generally spent more time on feminine household tasks than did fathers. Hypothesis 2 c posited that fathers in families characterized by more traditional gender role attitudes would spend more time with their sons. Analyses of parents' time with children revealed no univariate cluster effect for mothers' time spent with children.

A follow-up test of the univariate main effect showed that fathers spent significantly more time with their older children in the divergent group as compared to the traditional group. Taken together, this pattern suggests that fathers in the divergent group were relatively more involved with their children. Hypothesis 2 d posited that families characterized by more egalitarian gender role attitudes would be more likely to have girl-girl sibling dyads than boy-boy or mixed-sex sibling dyads. In addition, the egalitarian group had somewhat more sister-sister than brother-brother pairs.

In contrast to our hypothesis, however, mixed sex dyads sister-brother and brother-sister appeared to be distributed equally across the family types see Table 5. Hypothesis 3 posited that families characterized by incongruent gender role attitudes across family members would have higher levels of parent-child, marital, and sibling conflict compared to families characterized by congruent gender role attitudes across family members.

Inconsistent with our hypothesis, Tukey follow-up tests revealed higher levels of mother-child conflict in the traditional group compared to the egalitarian group and higher levels of father-child conflict in the traditional group compared to the other two family types. Although some researchers have begun to use person-oriented or pattern-analytic approaches to studying families e.

The current study demonstrates the utility of a pattern analytic approach for studying family systems. Our analyses revealed that families varied in their patterns of parents' and children's gender role attitudes. In the majority of families, there was congruence across four family members, in that all family members were either relatively more egalitarian or relatively more traditional as compared to individuals from other families. One group of families, however, showed an incongruent pattern in which both siblings displayed more egalitarian attitudes despite the more traditional views of their parents.

This pattern is consistent with family systems notions about within-family variability. The emergence of a divergent pattern also suggests that, whereas social learning processes explain children's gender role attitude development in some families, different mechanisms may be at work in other families. Our analyses revealed that between- and within-family comparisons provide somewhat different pictures of family attitude congruence and divergence: In both the divergent and traditional groups, mothers and fathers also differed in their attitudes, such that fathers in the divergent group were more traditional than their wives, and mothers in the traditional group were more traditional than their husbands.

As we have suggested, most studies of gender attitudes focus on individuals or dyads. Our family-oriented approach reveals a more complex set of processes than has been found in prior work. There were no instances in which two siblings differed from each other in their gender role attitudes. Social learning mechanisms may be functioning in these families such that younger siblings model the gender role attitudes of their older siblings e.

Future work exploring the relationships between siblings' gender role attitudes over time could provide further insight into the social learning processes that impact gender role development throughout adolescence. In exploring the conditions underlying these family patterns, the results were consistent with earlier studies in showing that parental education and income distinguished families with more traditional attitudes from those with more egalitarian attitudes e. The divergent group was also characterized by lower education and income, as would be expected given parents' traditionality; however, in this family type, as noted, the attitudes of children were more egalitarian.

Although the attitudes of parents in this group may have been grounded in socioeconomic factors, it appears that those of their children were not. In addition to background characteristics, family patterns of gender role attitudes also differed in terms of parents' time use within the family. The divergent group exhibited a seemingly paradoxical pattern.

Navigation menu

On the one hand, parents in this group displayed a more traditional division of household labor; on the other hand, fathers appeared to be more involved with their children compared to fathers in other family types. Although the traditional division of household labor fits with the traditional gender attitudes of the parents in this group, the relatively high involvement in children on the part of fathers suggested less traditionality. High paternal involvement in the divergent group is particularly noteworthy, given that girl-girl sibling dyads were over-represented in this group and that fathers in this group reported the most traditional attitudes.

Notably, although mothers in this group reported more traditional attitudes compared to other mothers, they were less traditional than their husbands. The findings illustrate the multidimensionality of gender: A person with traditional gender role attitudes does not necessarily exhibit gender-typed behaviors in all domains of life. The findings also provide some insight into the basis for the incongruence between parents' and children's attitudes in the divergent families.

When fathers differ in their attitudes and behaviors, their messages to their children about gender may be diluted. Despite the traditional attitudes of both parents, children in these families daughters in particular may notice the more egalitarian side of their fathers and react against their mother's traditional role in domestic labor. This highlights the complexity of socialization influences: Our results revealed that family patterns of gender role attitudes were linked to the sex constellation of the sibling dyad.

It was having not just one, but two girls, however, that increased families' chances of falling into the divergent group, and having not just one, but two boys that increased families' chances of falling into the traditional group. McHale and Crouter have previously demonstrated the important role that the sex of children plays in shaping family dynamics. Other research examining parents' differential treatment of siblings suggests that the sex constellation of siblings may influence the levels and types of parents' behaviors toward each of their children e.

Future researchers may gain new insights when moving beyond between- to within-family comparisons. Particularly important was the finding that having not one, but two children of a particular sex distinguished between the family clusters. In the case of the divergent group in which sister-sister pairs were more common, girls may have found it easier to express attitudes that were inconsistent with parents' when they had support from their sisters.

Similarly, the higher number of sister-sister pairs in the divergent group may explain mothers' less traditional attitudes relative to fathers, in the sense that having two daughters may encourage mothers to gravitate toward less traditional attitudes. In the traditional group, in contrast, the preponderance of boys in these families may have limited parents' exposure to and understanding of issues related to gender discrimination and equality that may arise when raising daughters.

Contrary to expectations, there was no evidence that the attitude incongruence of the divergent group had negative implications for parent-child relationships. Instead, there were higher levels of parent-child conflict in the traditional families. Importantly, this family type had an abundance of boy-boy pairs. Furthermore, the traditional gender role attitudes of parents may be coupled with more authoritarian parenting styles that have implications for conflict with sons and daughters.

Interestingly, mothers in this group were more traditional than fathers, and it is possible that this relative incongruence between parents' attitudes fueled conflict among parents and children. This investigation provides a contribution to understanding how families work as systems.

Nonetheless, there remain some issues to be addressed in future research. First, this study was limited to a cross-sectional analysis. In order to fully understand the processes involved in the formation of family patterns of attitudes, longitudinal studies are vital. Although it may seem logical to conclude that the sex constellation of sibling dyads exerted an influence on family patterns of attitudes rather than the other way around, a longitudinal analysis exploring the development of gender role attitudes within the family could help to pinpoint the unique way in which parents and children impact the family system.

Just as children's gender role attitudes may arise through developmental processes, patterns of family attitudes may ebb and flow. Similarly, longitudinal analyses are necessary to better understand what experiences and conditions precede the divergence of attitudes among family members and whether these differences have implications over the long-run.

A second limitation of our study pertains to the generalizability of the results. Although the participants reflected the demographic characteristics of the region in which they resided, the sample was fairly homogenous, both in terms of ethnicity and SES. Gender role orientations are not only multidimensional within family systems, but also across different family contexts. As such, these patterns of gender role attitudes may not be universal. The results of the cluster analysis should be replicated in other samples before drawing conclusions about the nature and correlates of family gender role attitude patterns.

Finally, the measure of parent-child conflict may be limited in its validity. Although the 11 domains assessed in the parent-child conflict scale certainly represent domains of family life that may trigger conflict, it is possible that these domains more closely represent household disciplinary or regulatory practices. Future studies could validate the findings in this study related to conflict by using alternative measures of parent-child conflict. In conclusion, our findings highlight the importance of measuring the gender role attitudes of multiple family members.

By examining family patterns of gender role attitudes rather than just focusing on individuals or single dyads, a deeper understanding of the processes involved in gender role attitude development, among both parents and children, can be gained. As this study demonstrates, gender role attitudes are connected to aspects of family life, including relationship quality and division of labor, and are shaped by the family context in which they are embedded.

The authors are grateful to their undergraduate and graduate student, staff, and faculty collaborators, as well as the dedicated families who participated in this project. Crouter and Susan M. National Center for Biotechnology Information , U. Author manuscript; available in PMC Feb 2. Author information Copyright and License information Disclaimer.

The Pennsylvania State University. See other articles in PMC that cite the published article. Abstract Study goals were to identify family patterns of gender role attitudes, to examine the conditions under which these patterns emerged, and to assess the implications of gender attitude patterns for family conflict. Introduction Although the importance of gender role attitudes in family dynamics has been of interest to researchers for several decades e.

Gender Roles Attitudes of Family Members: Congruence and Incongruence Our first goal was to identify family patterns of gender role attitudes. Congruence and Incongruence between Siblings We know much less about similarities and differences between siblings' gender role orientations than we do about those of marital and parent-child dyads. Conditions Underlying Family Patterns of Gender Roles Attitudes Our second goal was to explore the conditions under which family patterns of gender role attitudes emerged.

Family SES Evidence that socioeconomic factors may affect family gender role attitudes includes findings that women and men who have higher educational attainment and income express more egalitarian gender role orientations e. Parents' Time Spent on Gendered Household Tasks As noted, children learn about gender appropriate behaviors by observing the behaviors of their parents. Sex Constellation of Sibling Dyads A family systems perspective emphasizes the bidirectional influences between parents and children, and previous research suggests that children may influence parents in some of the same ways that parents influence children.

Gender Role Attitudes and Family Conflict Our third aim was to assess the implications of the family patterns of gender role attitudes for the quality of family relationships. Marital Conflict Marital quality has been found to be related to spousal similarity.

Parent-Child Conflict Only few studies examined intergenerational incongruence in attitudes and its links to parent-child relationships. Sibling Conflict Our review of the literature found no studies linking sibling attitude similarity with sibling conflict, and from a theoretical perspective, predictions are inconsistent.

Study Objectives and Hypotheses The present study was designed to address three research goals. We tested the following hypotheses. Cluster analyses will identify family patterns characterized by congruence and incongruence among family members' gender role attitudes. In families characterized by more traditional gender role attitudes, parents will have lower SES i.

In families characterized by more traditional gender role attitudes, parents will have a more traditional division of household labor. In families characterized by more traditional gender role attitudes, fathers will spend more time with sons. The group of families with more egalitarian gender role attitude patterns will include more families with girl-girl sibling dyads as compared to boy-boy or mixed-sex sibling dyads. Families characterized by incongruent gender role attitudes across family members will have higher levels of marital, parent-child, and sibling conflict compared to families characterized by congruent gender role attitudes across family members.

Method Participants Participants were two-parent families from two cohorts of a longitudinal study of family relationships. Procedure We collected data through home and phone interviews. Measures Background characteristics We collected information on family members' ages and parents' education level and income during home interviews with parents. Parents' time spent on feminine household tasks We assessed parents' participation in feminine household tasks via telephone interviews with parents. Parents' time with children We assessed parent-child shared time via phone interviews with youth.

Parents' marital conflict Parents completed a 5-item scale developed by Braiker and Kelly Parent-child conflict Youth completed an item measure adapted from Smetana Youth's conflict with siblings Youth completed a 5-item scale developed by Stocker and McHale Results Means and standard deviations of all variables in the study are shown in Table 1 separately for mothers, fathers, and female and male first- and secondborn siblings.

Open in a separate window. Patterns of Gender Role Attitudes Hypothesis 1 posited that cluster analyses would identify family patterns characterized by congruence and incongruence among family members' gender role attitudes. Conditions Underlying Family Patterns of Gender Role Attitudes To identify the conditions under which different family patterns of gender role attitudes emerged, we conducted a series of mixed model ANOVAs and chi-squared analysis.

Divergent Control Variables Mothers' Education Divergent Total Girl-Girl 22 6. Gender Role Attitudes and Family Conflicts Hypothesis 3 posited that families characterized by incongruent gender role attitudes across family members would have higher levels of parent-child, marital, and sibling conflict compared to families characterized by congruent gender role attitudes across family members.

Discussion Although some researchers have begun to use person-oriented or pattern-analytic approaches to studying families e. Conditions Underlying Family Patterns In exploring the conditions underlying these family patterns, the results were consistent with earlier studies in showing that parental education and income distinguished families with more traditional attitudes from those with more egalitarian attitudes e.

Family Gender Role Attitudes and Family Conflict Contrary to expectations, there was no evidence that the attitude incongruence of the divergent group had negative implications for parent-child relationships. Limitations and Future Directions This investigation provides a contribution to understanding how families work as systems. Acknowledgements The authors are grateful to their undergraduate and graduate student, staff, and faculty collaborators, as well as the dedicated families who participated in this project.

Parents and their children: The study of intergenerational influences. Sociology and Social Research. Five types of African-American marriages. Journal of Marriage and Family Therapy. The individual psychology of Alfred Adler. Basic Books; New York: Measures of children's sex typing in middle childhood. Australian Journal of Psychology. Gender-role attitudes in middle childhood: In what ways do parents influence their children? Atkinson J, Huston TL.

Sex role orientation and division of labor early in marriage. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. Atzaba-Poria N, Pike A. Are ethnic minority adolescents at risk for problem behaviour? Acculturation and intergenerational acculturation discrepancies in early adolescence. British Journal of Developmental Psychology.

Gender and development - Wikipedia

Bell RQ, Chapman M. Child effects in studies using experimental or brief longitudinal approaches to socialization. Benin MH, Agostinelli J. Husbands' and wives' satisfaction with the division of labor. Journal of Marriage and the Family. Studying individual development in an interindividual context: Lawrence Erlbaum; Mahway, NJ: The sex-typing of children's household labor: Parental influence on daughters and sons' housework.

The methods and problems of cluster analysis. Handbook of multivariate experimental psychology: Perspectives on individual differences. Plenum Press; New York: Feminist attitudes and support for gender equality: Opinion change in women and men, — A new look at similarity and attraction in marriage: Similarities in social-cognitive and communication skills as predictors of attraction and satisfaction.

Conflict in the development of close relationships. Burgess R, Huston T, editors. Social exchange in developing relationships. Academic Press; New York: Brooks C, Bolzendahl C. The transformation of US gender role attitudes: Cohort replacement, social-structural change, and ideological learning. Family employment status and gender role attitudes: A comparison of women and men college graduates. Congruency of identity style in married couples.

Journal of Family Issues. Collins WA, Russell G. Mother-child and father-child relationships in middle childhood and adolescence: Cox MJ, Paley B. The Annual Review of Psychology. The British Journal of Sociology. Children's influence on family dynamics: Lawrence Erlbaum; Mahwah, New Jersey: Gender as an organizing feature in parent-child relationships. Journal of Social Issues.

Does stress exacerbate parental differential treatment of siblings? Journal of Family Psychology.

Development of gender attitude traditionality across middle childhood and adolescence. The effect of assortative mating on the genetic composition of a population.

• The Elves and the Shoemaker (with panel zoom)/n/t/t/t - Classics Illustrated Junior?
• ;
• The Virgin and the Volcano (Lythande).
• ;

Parental influences on the gendered division of housework. Understanding women's educational and occupational choices: Applying the Eccles et al. Psychology of Women Quarterly. Epstein E, Guttman R. Mate selection in man: Feminism and family research. Fisher L, Ransom DC. An empirically derived typology of families: Relationships with adult health. Four types of premarital couples: Oxford Review of Economic Policy. Fathers, sons, and daughters: Differential paternal involvement in parenting.

Cluster analysis in family psychology research. Do they make, and then break, our relationships? Linking changes in whole family functioning and children's externalizing behavior across the elementary school years. Perceptions of contributing factors. American Journal of Family Therapy. The impact of social background on gender-role ideology.

Adult attitudes about assignments of household chores to male and female children. Luo S, Klohnen EC. One view is that the crisis has affected women disproportionately and that there is a need for alternative economic structures in which investment in social reproduction needs to be given more weight. Examples for these sectors are the service sector or wholesale retail trade. There are different views among feminists on whether neoliberal economic policies have more positive or negative impacts on women.

In the post-war era, feminist scholars such as Elizabeth Wilson [86] criticized state capitalism and the welfare state as a tool to oppress women.

• Family Patterns of Gender Role Attitudes!
• Ken Ward in the Jungle, Thrilling Adventures in Tropical Wilds ; Classic American Adventure Story.
• Family Patterns of Gender Role Attitudes.
• Introduction.
• .
• ;
• ?

Therefore, neoliberal economic policies featuring privatization and deregulation , hence a reduction of the influence of the state and more individual freedom was argued to improve conditions for women. This anti-welfare state thinking arguably led to feminist support for neoliberal ideas embarking on a macroeconomic policy level deregulation and a reduced role of the state. Therefore, some scholars in the field argue that feminism , especially during its second wave , has contributed key ideas to Neoliberalism that, according to these authors, creates new forms of inequality and exploitation.

As a reaction to the phenomenon that some forms of feminism are increasingly interwoven with capitalism, many suggestions on how to name these movements have emerged in the feminist literature. Theoretical approaches Advocated chiefly by the World Bank , smart economics is an approach to define gender equality as an integral part of economic development and it aims to spur development through investing more efficiently in women and girls. Its approach identifies women are relatively underinvested source of development and it defines gender equality an opportunity of higher return investment.

The thinking behind smart economics dates back, at least, to the lost decade of the Structural Adjustment Policies SAPs in the s. For example, the Bank turned to researches of Whitehead that evidenced a greater female-control of household income is associated with better outcomes for children's welfare [94] and Jeffery and Jeffery who analyzed the positive correlation between female education and lower fertility rates.

Gender Equality and Development. Other international organizations , particular UN families, have so far endorsed the approach of smart economics. The then-president of the World Bank Robert B. Investing in them is not only fair, it is a smart economic move. Criticisms From the mids, the approach of smart economics and its chief proponent —World Bank— met a wide range of criticisms and denouncements. These discontents can be broadly categorized into three major claims; Subordination of Intrinsic Value; Ignorance for the need of systemic transformation; Feminisation of responsibility; Overemphasized efficiency; and Opportunistic pragmatism.

This is not exhaustive list of criticisms, but the list aims to highlight different emphasis among existing criticisms. Rather a critique made is that the World Bank's gender policy utilizes gender equality as an ends means rather than analyzing root causes for economic disparities and gender equity. A wide range of scholars and practitioners has criticized that smart economics rather endorse the current status-quo of gender inequality and keep silence for the demand of institutional reform. This may have attractions in strategic terms, enabling us to access resources for work focusing on supporting the individual agency of women and girls, but risks aggravating many of the complex problems that gender and development seeks to transform.

Other approaches with different paradigms have also played a historically important role in advancing theories and practices in gender and development. The structuralist debate was first triggered by Marxist and socialist feminists. Marxism, particularly through alternative models of state socialist development practiced in China and Cuba , [] challenged the dominant liberal approach over time.

Neo-Marxist proponents focused on the role of the post-colonial state in development in general and also on localized class struggles. Dependency theorists opposed that liberal development models, including the attempt to incorporate women into the existing global capitalism, was in fact nothing more than the "development of underdevelopment. In the s, there also emerged "a sustained questioning by post-structuralist critics of the development paradigm as a narrative of progress and as an achievable enterprise.

Within the liberal paradigm of women and development, various criticism have emerged. The Basic Needs BN approach began to pose questions to the focus on growth and income as indicators of development. It was heavily influenced by Sen and Nussabaum's capability approach , which was more gender sensitive than BN and focused on expanding human freedom.

From a perspective of sustainable development , ecofeminists articulated the direct link between colonialism and environmental degradation, which resulted in degradation of women's lives themselves. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. This article is about the discipline. This article's tone or style may not reflect the encyclopedic tone used on Wikipedia. See Wikipedia's guide to writing better articles for suggestions. August Learn how and when to remove this template message. International Economic Development Council.

Retrieved 28 November Gender Planning and Development. Theory, Practice and Training. Gender, development, and globalization: Retrieved 10 November World Legal Information Institute. Journal of International Relations and Development. Berkeley University of California: College of Natural Resources.

Retrieved 9 December Women and World Development. Retrieved 22 November Producing women and progress in Zimbabwe: Overcoming the constraints" PDF. Trends in Research and Practice. Theoretical perspectives on gender and development. Conceptual Shifts in the Women and Development Discourse": Gender and Myth in the Aftermath of the Financial Crisis". Feminist Strategies in Global Governance: Gender, Development, and Globalization: Economics as if All People Mattered. Retrieved 5 November An Evaluation of World Bank Support, Alternatives to Neoliberalism and the Crisis. Outsourcing and labour substitution among french manufacturing firms".

Gender and development

Federally Employed Women, Inc. The Economics of Microfinance. Banker to the Poor: Micro-Lending and the Battle against World Poverty". Review of Radical Political Economics. The Journal of African History. International Journal of Financial Research. Check date values in: Journal of Law and Commerce.

Asian Journal of Women's Studies. Archives of the Church of Uganda Online. A new culture of women's empowerment in Rajasthan? Fondation Maison des sciences de l'homme. Retrieved 2 November Retrieved 27 November Gender Development and Globalization: Retrieved 18 December Women and the Welfare State. Retrieved 25 November The Aftermath of Feminism: Gender, Culture and Social Change. Some concerns about the preparatory process and the prospects for paradigm change".

Meeting practical and strategic gender needs". Of marriage and the market: Feminist visions of development: Silver Bullet or Passing Fancy? Retrieved 1 December Gender Equality and Development". Gender Equality and Development: The state of the world's children United Nations Children's Fund. Global Monitoring Report The New York Times.

Girls in the Global Economy. Adding it All Up. A critique of the World Development Report". Gender mainstreaming in poverty eradication and the Millennium development goals a handbook for policy-makers and other stakeholders. Capitalism and underdevelopment in Latin America: The women, gender and development reader 2nd ed. Development as freedom 1st publ. Employment, growth, and basic needs: The death of nature: Being Women and Men in Africa Today: Bradshaw, Sarah May